Boost app’s engagement with powerful native screens. Join our live webinar. Register Now
Convert your website to an app, design custom screens, engage users, and track insights — all with Twinr.
Get customized mobile app solutions for every industry and platform.
Your knowledge hub for seamless mobile app creation and optimization!
Home » Blogs » How Loyalty Programs Drive Repeat Business in Food Services
By Gaurav Parvadiya | Last Updated On June 16th, 2025
The food service industry is one of the most competitive ones in today’s businesses. With so many choices like dine-in, takeout, and delivery, it’s never been harder for brands to keep their customers loyal. It can really cost five times more to get a new customer than to keep an old one. So, repeat business is not only important, it’s necessary for growth to continue.
Customers who are loyal often spend more, come back more often, and speak out in public. Not only are they customers, but they also bring in money for the business. A Harvard Business School study found that increasing customer retention by just 5% can lead to a profit increase of 25% to 95%. That kind of return makes it clear: loyalty isn’t a bonus; it’s a strategy. This lays the foundation for how to increase customer loyalty in food services.
This is where loyalty programs for restaurants come in. Originally, these programs developed from basic punch cards to data-driven, app-integrated experiences with real-time rewards, personalization, and exclusivity, meant to inspire frequent visits and reward consistent behavior. This blog will look at why loyalty programs matter, how they operate in the food service environment, and how best to create them for the most effect.
A loyalty program in the food services is a marketing tactic used by companies to attract clients to come back to business. Loyalty programs can take many different forms, from shop credit cards to fully featured mobile apps to discounts and prizes. They serve as essential restaurant rewards program benefits which helps in long-term engagement and repeat order.
There are several common types of loyalty programs used in the food service industry:
Customers get points for every purchase, which they can then use to get deals or freebies. For example, a coffee shop might give you one point for every dollar you spend and let you exchange 50 points for a free drink. Starbucks’ Rewards program is a well-known example of a point-based system that works well.
These methods are very flexible and can be easily turned into games to get more people involved. Companies can reward people for doing certain things, like trying new menu items or visiting during off-peak hours, by giving them extra points. This is also one of the most effective customer loyalty strategies for cafes, where small incentives go a long way in building daily repeat business.
These offer escalating rewards as customers reach new spending milestones. A fast-casual chain might have Silver, Gold, and Platinum levels, with perks like priority seating or exclusive menu items.
Tiered models create a sense of progression, which taps into consumer psychology. The higher the tier, the more status a customer feels. It’s not just about the reward, it’s about belonging to an elite club.
Customers pay a recurring fee for regular perks, like free delivery or a daily coffee. Panera’s Unlimited Sip Club is a subscription model that offers one free drink every two hours for a monthly fee.
These programs are great for building predictable, recurring revenue. They also encourage daily engagement, making them ideal for quick-service models where frequency drives profit.
A simple yet effective strategy where customers get a free item after a set number of purchases. Think of a frozen yogurt shop offering a free cup after ten purchases.
While analog in origin, punch cards have gone digital with app-based tracking. They’re familiar, easy to understand, and ideal for businesses with repeatable, low-cost offerings.
Each type has its place. For high-frequency, low-ticket items (like coffee or quick bites), punch cards or points systems work well. For higher-end or delivery-focused operations, tiered and subscription models offer better long-term value.
Read More:- The Rise of Mobile Ordering: How Restaurants
Value is what makes relationships last, and loyalty programs help customers feel that value. When people know they are getting something back for every dollar they spend, they are more likely to come back than look for other options.
A study found that people who are members of reward programs make 12–18% more money a year than people who are not members. This effect might be more noticeable in food service, where familiarity and repetition are important.
Restaurants can keep customers coming back by giving them regular rewards, special deals, and perks that are tailored to their needs. These are directly related to how loyalty apps increase repeat orders. It would be through data-driven personalization and mobile push engagement.
Customers engaged in loyalty programs are more likely to increase their spend per order. Why? Because earning points or hitting a milestone gives them an extra reason to add a dessert, upsize a meal, or try a new item. Rewards create a psychological incentive to ‘make it count.’
Restaurants can also use targeted promotions to drive higher AOV. For instance, offering double points on orders over a certain value encourages customers to spend a little more to hit the target. Chick-fil-A often runs such promotions within their app, leading to measurable upticks in order size.
Additionally, upselling and cross-selling become easier within a loyalty context. When customers know they’re working toward a reward, they’re more receptive to suggestions that help them get there faster, like adding a side or drink.
Loyalty programs for restaurants are also powerful data engines. Every scan, swipe, or tap reveals preferences, favorite items, order frequency, peak times. This data can inform everything from personalized marketing to inventory planning.
For example, if a pizza restaurant sees a customer orders every Friday night, they can automate an offer each Friday afternoon. Or if a customer always orders gluten-free, the app can highlight new gluten-free menu items first.
Better data leads to smarter decisions. Restaurants can optimize their menus, test pricing strategies, and refine promotions. It transforms the marketing team’s role from guesswork to precision.
In crowded markets, loyalty programs help differentiate a brand. While competitors fight for awareness, loyalty-driven restaurants focus on retention, often the more profitable battlefield.
Exclusive member-only offers, early access to menu drops, or birthday gifts all help reinforce that a brand sees the customer as more than a transaction. This personalized experience builds brand loyalty and turns regulars into advocates.
Restaurants that combine loyalty with great service often enjoy stronger word-of-mouth referrals. A customer who earns rewards and feels appreciated is more likely to recommend your spot to friends and family.
Yes, when implemented thoughtfully, they work exceptionally well. Studies show loyalty program members visit restaurants 20% more frequently and spend 30% more per visit compared to non-members. Programs like Domino’s Piece of the Pie Rewards and Dunkin’s DD Perks have shown how gamified, app-driven systems can translate directly into sales growth.
Even independent restaurants can benefit with the right tools. Whether using platforms like Peblla or integrating with POS systems, the key is to keep the program simple, valuable, and well-communicated to the customer.
A great loyalty program starts with clear goals. Are you looking to increase visit frequency, boost AOV, or drive digital engagement? Once you’ve defined your objectives, you can design a program that aligns with customer behavior. Each of these goals aligns with key principles of how to increase customer loyalty in food services and making lifetime value.
Rewarding the right action is crucial. For quick-service restaurants, that might mean incentivizing morning coffee runs. For higher-end establishments, rewarding dinner reservations or large group orders could be more appropriate.
The program type, points, tiers, subscriptions, should all follow your typical client path. For smoothies, punch cards could be ideal but for a food delivery business, memberships would be appropriate.
Including loyalty programs into your current IT stack is not negotiable. Make sure your customer communication tools, ordering system, and POS system all coordinate. Applications for mobile-first loyalty, such as those backed by Peblla, make managing simple for operators and user experience seamless.
Avoid common traps: don’t make rewards too hard to reach, and don’t bombard users with irrelevant messages. And above all, listen, customer feedback will guide how your program evolves.
To evaluate how well your loyalty program is working, focus on key metrics:
CLV is how much money a business thinks a customer will spend over the course of their relationship with them. Customers who are loyal, valuable, frequently purchase, and regularly interact with the company are indicators of a higher CLV.
According to Forrester study, 81% of respondents measure customer lifetime value. You may already know this loyalty metric. But most of the time, measuring CLV is done after the fact by keeping track of what people bought, when, how, etc.
Coming back to buy again and again is the best way to show that you care about a brand. The repeat purchase rate shows what number of customers buy more than one thing during a certain time period.
A good rate of repeat purchases shows that your loyalty program is doing a good job of building long-term relationships with customers (beyond the original incentives). Also, customers who buy from you again and again tend to spend more over time, which leads to a higher CLV and more long-term income.
Are members spending more per visit? Compare AOV between program members and regular customers. If the loyalty program is effective, you should see a noticeable lift.
High redemption rates suggest that rewards are desirable and accessible. Low rates may indicate that rewards are too hard to earn, or not valuable enough.
Use NPS surveys, in-app ratings, or post-purchase questions to gauge how customers feel about the program. Feedback can uncover areas to improve and opportunities to surprise and delight.
Monitoring these KPIs allows for ongoing refinement. If certain perks aren’t being used, test new ones. If churn increases, review friction points. A good loyalty program isn’t static, it’s always evolving.
Read More:- How to create a restaurant app without coding
Loyalty programs in the food industry isn’t just a way to generate revenue for your business; it’s also a way to grow it. When there aren’t many sales and a lot of competition, keeping customers is the most reliable thing you can do.
Loyalty can lead to more visits, bigger orders, and stronger emotional ties if you have the right structure, technology, and knowledge. Whether you’re running a small café or a large restaurant chain, applying smart customer loyalty strategies for cafes or casual diners helps maintain competitive advantage. Start small, keep the customer in mind, and make changes based on what works. Customers who stick with you are the ones you want to keep.
Q.1 What is the most effective type of loyalty program for a small restaurant?
Punch-card or points-based systems tend to work well for small businesses due to ease of implementation and clarity for customers.
Q.2 How can technology enhance the effectiveness of loyalty programs?
Mobile apps, integrated POS systems, and platforms like Peblla make it easy to track behavior, deliver personalized offers, and measure performance.
Q.3 What are some cost-effective ways to implement a loyalty program?
Start with digital punch cards or partner with third-party apps that offer white-label solutions. Simplicity is key.
Q.4 How do loyalty programs impact customer satisfaction?
They make customers feel valued, increase repeat visits, and often improve service quality through data insights.
Q.5 Can loyalty programs be integrated with online ordering systems?
Absolutely. Many platforms now offer seamless loyalty tracking for both in-store and online purchases.
Gaurav is the founder and CEO of Twinr, a tech entrepreneur with a decade of experience and a passion for SaaS. With a Master's degree in Computer Science, he specializes in no-code development, driving innovation in the mobile app industry. When he's not busy growing the company, you'll find him writing about tech, growth, software development, e-commerce, and occasionally sneaking in a game of badminton.